Traitorous

We are not told our students’ charges: we are supposed to meet them as who they are in the classroom, not who they had been before. We judge them solely on the merits of their work in our class, a haven from the judgement they already feel in prison and from society as they prepare for trial. I wonder, at first, what brought each of these men here but as I grow close to them over the days and weeks, I find it easy to live in the present with them.
Bored with private tutoring, I became a volunteer teacher at the prison so I could do something meaningful with my skills.
Maybe, too, I did it because I have just come out of an abusive relationship which still feels like a series of terrible choices on my part. The anger I feel toward my abuser pales in comparison to the anger I feel toward myself, the hot shame of staying with someone who degraded me, who expressed amazement that I had an Ivy League degree because I was the “dumbest cunt” he had ever met, who pushed me down flights of stairs and forced me on nights I “didn’t listen” to sleep on a leaky air mattress that would be flat by morning.
Maybe I, too, want to be in a place for a few hours a week where no one knows my past, where if I put on my best face, a new future is there for the taking.
My abuser used to say to me, with more glee than remorse, you’ll never be able to be in a relationship again, you’ll never live a normal life, I fucked you up too much.
Maybe I show up because I need, desperately, to believe he is wrong, that there is no such thing as “no coming back.”
My students are pre-trial, waiting for their day in court in the federal prison in Sunset Park which stretches a whole city block, the facility a mass of concrete right on the Gowanus Bay, though there are few windows from which to see the dark water and passing barges.
I show up every week and teach a course on literature and life skills. We read Ishmael Beah’s A Long Way Gone, a memoir about being drafted into child soldierhood in Somalia and the students discuss all the ways moral issues might have been sticky and twisted in their own lives, what it feels like to live a life you wish you could escape from. We work on their resumes and practice interview skills: when to reveal their time in prison, how to portray it.
I could say one of my skills is works well with others, one student offers. I'm hip to hip all day long with people and I never got into a single fight here!
The class laughs and we talk about all the other ways prison survival skills could become potential workplace skills. Many of their charges are likely to carry relatively short sentences, just a few years; the future they are preparing for is just around the corner. For the others, it helps to pass the time, to imagine life outside of here, even if it’s just a dot in the distance.
In the beginning, before we are comfortable with each other, the class discussions sometimes falter. I ask questions and they hang in the air, my eyes darting around the room as my palms sweat. We are frequently saved by one student, Ethan, shooting up his hand, after which the others follow.
Ethan has a reddish beard and a stocky build and he is always at least five minutes early to class, arriving with his tan prison-issued shirt tucked into his matching pants. He does every single homework assignment above and beyond what is asked. He bolsters his classmates, always adding on to their insights and never talking over.
I am not surprised to learn he is also a teacher on the inside, instructing his fellow inmates in sign language, math, and CPR. He is one of only a few white men in the class and the only one born in the US. He seems to maneuver his minority status with grace. He doesn’t try to be who he is not, affecting an inauthentic vernacular or puffing up his toughness, but he also doesn’t isolate himself. He is, without qualification, a delight to have in class.
One time I mention my dogs during our weekly “highs and lows” check-in and the men’s ears perk up.
What kind of dogs? they want to know. What breed?
Pit mixes, I tell them, rescue mutts.
Oh those are some of the nicest dogs, actually, right?
For sure, I tell them, they get a bad rap as a breed, but you have to look at them individually.
This, they understand.
Instructors aren’t allowed to bring their phones past security so I print out photos of my dogs with Santa Claus at a pop-up shoot we’d gone to. Sinatra, black with a white chest, staring straight at the camera, confident. Petunia, gray and white, in profile, charmingly eyeing the man in the red suit.
At the beginning of the next class I show them to a few students and as the others trickle in they pass along the message like a game of telephone, beckoning each newcomer over excitedly: it’s her dogs, it’s pictures of her dogs.
The next class, before we begin, Ethan walks right up to me instead of to his seat. He is holding a picture, the edges worn from handling.
My dog, he says, sticking it in front of me for assessment. He is poker-faced as I examine the brown and black canine in the picture, lying on its side, content.
I understand what he is asking for, for me to see him as someone who exists outside of here, who was also once entrusted with the care of another.
He’s really cute, I tell him and his face breaks into a grin.
We start our class discussion reviewing their journal entry from the week prior: What keeps you hopeful?
A moment as I scan the room, tapping my index finger and thumb, hoping this question isn’t too far-fetched or painful, the silence hanging.
Ethan, star student, blessedly raises his hand.
My family, he says, my wife and two boys, they are right here—he taps his temple—all the time. Twenty-four seven. You have to have something to live for.
The other men nod, vigorously.
For me it’s just work, home, church on the weekends. My wife and I trade off, watching the kids and doing community service with the church.
Ethan has mentioned his religious commitment before, clearly takes it seriously, though he is not a proselytizer. It seems, instead, to center his life in a helpful way.
It takes no work for me to imagine him again on the outside, thriving.
One week we are playing a community building game where the men choose a slip of paper from a pile in the center of our semi-circle and select any classmate to answer the question on it. Someone pulls “If you could relive any thirty seconds of your life, what would they be?” and calls on Roger, who tells us a story about being exhausted after work, dozing on the couch, when his three-year-old daughter shook him awake, pointing to her mouth, asking for food. Eyes barely open, he tells her to ask her mother.
No Daddy, she says, I want you.
A heaviness falls over the room for just a moment. It is striped with sweetness but still weighs ten tons. In our semi-circle there are smiles, the shitty, sad ones, the ones that show a remembrance, tucked away, of everything happening right now without them.
You got up? Terrell asks.
Kind laughs break the tension.
When it’s your kid? Ethan says. Of course he did.
Roger looks at him, his mouth a straight line, his eyelashes wet and nods.
One of the other students in class, Alex, Russian-born and Brooklyn-bred with a thick head of silver hair, asks me once if I feel scared coming into the prison. I shake my head. I honestly don’t. There are guards in the prison and men in this room who want to be better. I have been in a scarier place.
Good, he tells me, because you know if anyone outside this room so much as plucked a hair from your head we would be on them before that hair touched the ground.
I believe him. I feel nothing but warmth and optimism toward him and his classmates. I am honored that they entrust me as a facilitator on their guide to different choices, a better future.
I love our Wednesday afternoon classes and as our graduation ceremony nears I feel a sense of deflation.
I wish this class were longer, a few students say in our final class as they reflect on what they learned, how they’ve changed as people.
Me too, I say.
In here, I have been able to remember who I was before my relationship: a competent, emotionally regulated adult, not someone knocking on a friend’s door at 3 am, bawling, asking if I can stay there because I have been kicked out of my home, again. But twelve weeks doesn’t feel like quite enough time to exorcise the ghosts haunting me. The ones that pipe up every time I get my belongings from my locker in the prison lobby and make my way back outside and whisper You’re still broken.
Mostly, though, I care about these students, deeply, and I will miss them and our weekly meetings.
We vote for a graduation speaker and Ethan is chosen by a landslide. He bows his head when the results are announced and thanks his fellow classmates.
At our graduation ceremony Ethan’s message is secular, but his delivery shows traces of his work in a church, a preacher-like call to his voice.
You are all special, you all have purpose, and I am asking you to remember that, and to never, ever give up.
Their heads nod as he orates, his words simple and full of grace.
For our ceremony I am required to write a short paragraph about each of the students and read it aloud before they receive their certificate of completion. This will later be the basis for the letter of recommendation we provide every successful graduate to be shared with the judge in their case. We are told this can sometimes influence a judge toward leniency in sentencing.
I write with eager benevolence, calling Ethan “thoughtful, eager to learn, observant.” I commend him as “a perfect example of ‘step up, step back’—someone who contributes to class with razor sharp insights but also listens to his fellow classmates.”
Before I hand him his certification, I note my admiration in how he has made himself “vulnerable at times in a way that was undoubtedly hard,” thinking of when he spoke tearfully of the chasm he felt inside, missing his family. He shakes my hand and thanks me and tells me what a terrific teacher I have been.
It is March 2020 and the prison shuts down to outsiders completely one week later. We made it just in time.
We are invited, as a show of support, to attend our students’ trials or sentencing hearings in the months, sometimes even years after the class ends. Whenever possible I take the short subway ride to downtown Brooklyn to attend.
Though I am never called on to speak, my students’ lawyers always point me out to the judge, noting I am the writer of the letter they received and I hope it gives some more credence to my words that I come in person.
That October Ethan’s lawyer contacts me and asks if I am available to call in to Ethan’s sentencing hearing the following month, to be held virtually due to the ongoing pandemic. I won’t speak but he will let the judge know I am on the call. In a time where so many efforts feel futile, I agree, for whatever it could be worth.
The day of the call I am restless. I only have a half hour before I need to leave the house for an in-person tutoring session. Prior hearings have been anywhere from a half hour to an hour plus. I hope this one is short. The call is supposed to start at 12:30 but doesn’t begin until 12:41 and I am pacing. My earpiece in, I tidy my apartment, water my plants, make sure my work bag is ready.
The court officer takes a roll call of everyone on the line. Ethan’s lawyer notes that I am the teacher who wrote Ethan’s letter of recommendation and the judge thanks me for my time. A pause. The judge clears his throat.
I was told Victim 1 would be on the line.
I stop moving. Victim? I never learn my students' charges until I am at the hearings. If I don’t go, I never find out. I have sat through sentencing hearings for tax fraud and robbery and racketeering. Usually the judge talks about the ways my students have disappointed their families and themselves and how they need to truly contemplate that. There has never been any “Victim” present. For Ethan? What the fuck is going on?
There is static on the line and then we hear the prosecutor’s voice—Yes, Victim 1 is here. As well as Victim 2.
The judge thanks them for their time and apologizes for addressing them anonymously, noting this is per their request, not due to a lack of respect.
The judge finishes roll call and then states that it is time for Victim 1 to give her statement.
Victim 1 begins. There is a trace of a working class accent, maybe New York. I can tell she is technically young but there is a world weariness to her voice that is almost, but not quite, eclipsed by the urgent pace. There are no ums; she has practiced this. I can picture a set of handwritten notes in neat bubble letters.
For several minutes she speaks not to the judge or Ethan or even the court as a whole. She speaks directly to Victim 2. She tells her how tremendously sorry she is, how she lives under a boulder of guilt that she will carry her whole life. Had she spoken up sooner, Victim 2 may not have suffered. She will never forgive herself for this. She apologizes over and over. Victim 2 does not, maybe cannot, respond.
I stand frozen as she speaks.
I think of the letter I wrote to the judge in support of Ethan describing him as “a model student in our program.”
I look at my watch and realize I will be late for work. I keep my earpiece in, leave my apartment and walk down my block toward the subway, my chest tight.
As I walk, Victim 1 states she did not deserve what happened to her “simply because I had a vagina.” She states unwaveringly that Ethan is a danger to society and should never be let out.
It is the first cold day of fall. I pass flaming orange leaves and think about how I wrote that Ethan “cares very, very deeply about his family” and that “he was highly focused, determined that when he was done serving his time, he would be the provider his family needs and a role model for his children and community members.”
I suddenly wonder if the Victims read my letter. If they seethed with rage when they heard I was on the line, how they must hate me and think I am a woman who doesn’t believe or support other women.
For another half hour the hearing continues. The judge details the sentencing statutes he must follow. As he works through the charges he reads every character of the sentencing guidelines, all the letters and numbers and dots. He specifies capitals and lower cases.
He reads this alphanumeric soup and I wish I could unmute myself and shout to Victim 1 and Victim 2 I didn’t know! I was just writing about him in my class. I had no idea.
And if I had?
Our program was literally called “Focus Forward.” We worked with the person in front us, not their past. I had said those words so many times. Only now did it feel parroted and naive.
I imagine, for the first time—how is this the first time I am thinking of this?—someone writing a recommendation letter for my abuser. I picture him, suddenly, in our semi-circle of chairs, talking about how his father abandoned him, how he knows he can be a better person, he just made some mistakes, he has goals, he has dreams. I feel hot in the face as I imagine his slick words and good eye contact, selling this bit, and the convenient lack of mention of the woman who once found herself on the train, trying to catch her breath a good week after he had battered her ribcage.
The judge notes that in sentencing he must consider Ethan’s military record and ensuing PTSD, his childhood abuse, his strong family ties, his teaching in prison and his many educational certificates. He also notes that Ethan’s charges were against minors and the damage done to them irreversible. He sentences him to three hundred months.
On the train I pull out my phone’s calculator and do the math. Twenty-five years. I wonder what his wife and sons will do while he is imprisoned for twenty-five years. His dog, of course, will die.
In the sentencing the judge notes that Ethan earned his victims’ trust through his involvement as a youth minister. The court record notes that at the time of the crime Victim 1 was fifteen. According to the record Ethan “persuaded Victim-1 to engage in sexually explicit activity, photograph and video it, and transmit it to him via text.” He also sent “images of his erect penis” and “images of him masturbating” to her. Things escalated with Victim 2 and I begin to understand Victim 1’s apology. The record shows that for almost three years Ethan “persuaded, induced, and enticed a female minor (“Victim-2”) to engage in illegal sexual activity.” Victim 2 was entering 8th grade, twelve or thirteen years old, when Ethan sexually abused her. When a search warrant was executed in connection with the investigation they found sexually explicit images and videos of her and “hundreds of other images of child pornography.”
In my letter I wrote “Your Honor, it has been a true pleasure having Ethan in my class as a student. I see in Ethan someone who is very aware of their past faults and determined to right those wrongs.”
Was he? How could he ever right this wrong for those girls? Victim 2 had elected not to speak on the sentencing call. How much of that was a choice? Has she been able to craft anything that even resembled a normal life in the years since he abused her?
I think about how every time I asked Ethan how he was in those moments before class started, he would list the many things he had on his plate: the classes he was teaching, the classes he was taking, what is referred to as “prison busy,” a euphemism to mask how very long each day could be. He told me he had not a minute to waste—he knew he had to serve time but he was going to make the most of it, by improving himself and those around him to the best of his ability.
Sitting on the train that day after the hearing ends, I wonder if after he is sentenced to three hundred months he still feels like he has not a minute to waste. I wonder if three hundred months brings any solace to Victim 1 and Victim 2. In three hundred months would Victim 1 still be carrying Victim 2’s sorrow on her back?
The train barrels down the tunnel under Lexington Ave and I wonder why, as a woman coming out of an abusive relationship, my instinct was to teach in a prison, to align myself with perpetrators. I could have volunteered at a women’s shelter for victims of domestic violence. What base, shameful impulse made it more attractive to spend time with the people who did the hurting, those with power, and pretend I was more like them than the people who got hurt?
My abuser had promised me the day I left that that apology you’re waiting for is never going to come. In the prison, the men acted contrite and remorseful and thanked me, over and over, for my time and effort. Is that how I ended up there, seeking some sort of satisfaction I wasn’t going to get elsewhere?
My head spins.
I text the head of our program that evening and ask him for a phone call. When we talk the next day I tell him that can never happen again. I need to know what I’m facing. I rant, my voice shaking, for several minutes. I should have known, I should have known. He apologizes profusely. He tells me the prison usually vets the students and tries to avoid those with murder or rape charges. This, he says ruefully, must have slipped through.
That night as I’m going to bed I think about the explicit rule of the program that students do not talk about their cases in class.
First, we are not lawyers, we tell them. We cannot offer you legal advice. And, second, we are not concerned with what you did in the past. We are concerned with your present and future.
I wonder if Ethan was glad to have me at the hearing, a show of support from his present, a promise for his ability to create a better future. Or if he was filled with shame and embarrassment, if he wished I had sent my letter and not showed, blissfully ignorant of how he had arrived in my class, hoping I assumed he had merely brought some stolen goods across state lines or something.
When I spoke to my supervisor I told him I wish I had known the charges going into the hearing but that I still believed in the program’s “no charges talk” policy. I wondered if that was true. If a clean slate policy—“we only care about you now, here”—is a slap in the face to the victims whose own slates remain marred and filthy, my adherence to it tantamount to being an accessory to the crime.
When I was my best self I wanted my abuser to be granted the chance and given the support to change, to be a better person out there in the world. It would not change my hurt but I wanted this for all the future people he would not hurt. There is a gap miles wide, though, between an adult in an abusive, consensual relationship who wants to show grace and two minors who were vilely abused by their youth minister.
I do not know their thoughts on the great human capacity to change and what it means to have a redemption story and what it means to be the footnote in someone else’s. I wonder what happens when redemption gets taken off the table, for any of us.
I wonder if Victim 1 will ever stop feeling guilty, if being able to talk to Victim 2 and cry together on a staticky phone line, in front of their abuser and a teacher who had sung his praises, helped at all.
If it was fair for me to overlay my own desire for redemption onto someone else’s story of pain. If it was fair that a stranger, not the victim, gets to decide someone has changed and yet who else but a stranger could have?
I can’t tell you if I would write the same letter.
*names have been changed
Elizabeth Irwin is a playwright, essayist, and teacher. Her plays have been produced by theaters including Playwrights Realm, Teatro Vista, Marin Theater and Seattle Rep and she has been a writing fellow at the Public Theater and Soho Rep. In her free time she dives with sharks and walks dogs at the city shelter.




Comments