Field Reports

Over the weeks they crossed paths in the lobby, the elevator, the roof deck with its view of Manhattan. She was new to New York, on an assignment as a liaison for humanitarian agencies, he’d heard from an acquaintance. Mid-thirties, no more than that. Her profile fit in. In a ninety-four-unit building, faces changed often.
She struck him as confident, someone who could hold her own in high-stakes meetings or move with ease in crisis zones. She wore colorful shirts and jeans, or workout clothes. Her only adornment was the smooth, pale green ring she wore on the middle finger of her right hand, which to him signified it wasn’t for show, but carried some larger meaning.
It wasn’t until he talked with her at length out front of the building that he found out she was from Chicago.
“From the accent, my guess was Detroit.”
“Four hours away, you were close.”
Before parting ways, they exchanged names.
“Mia.”
“James.”
When he asked her to have coffee with him sometime, she said, “I look forward to doing that.”
Her name was Mia Baldwin. The next Sunday they walked to Café Grumpy.
“My favorite coffee in the city,” he said.
She hadn’t been to it, but she knew of it from the famous HBO series.
They took their cappuccinos to the back where others sat, their eyes locked on laptops. Small, framed paintings and photos by local artists hung on the walls, and in one corner a community bookshelf overflowed with books.
When she mentioned the previous day’s march from Bryant Park to Madison Square, he considered it for a moment. Tensions between protesters and authorities had led to almost a hundred arrests.
“I was there with friends, sure,” he said. “Almost three years into it, I don’t see them ending. Nor do I see them doing much to sway the conduct of a hostile government. Maybe I should feel differently. What do you think?”
“I’m in your camp, not much has resulted,” she said. “Since I’ve been back, I haven’t gone to any. I don’t take much interest in that sort of thing.”
He watched her, wondering where she was back from and how long she’d been away?
“Six years,” she said. “Frankfurt, Istanbul, Buenos Aires.”
In Frankfurt, she worked for a subcontractor to the European External Action Service reporting on whether governments were honoring international law in unstable regions. Her title was Monitoring Liaison. That meant she spent her days staring at a screen, cross-referencing foreign-ministry statements with NGO field reports, stitching together the parts of the story Western governments preferred to erase.
Istanbul was different. She held a regional post with a foundation funding programs against human rights abuses. The mission was apolitical, or so it was said. Her job was evaluation, interviewing families of the disappeared, documenting arrests, recording intimidation. Nothing she filed ever made the news. She never knew what became of her reports.
“Sounds a lot like what’s going on here,” he said.
She smiled, but didn’t react.
Overall, she preferred Istanbul over Frankfurt. Beyoğlu was exciting. She was surprised the nightlife was as alive as it was.
There had been a man there she connected with. A journalist. In public, they never used each other’s real names. She couldn’t remember if that had been his rule or hers.
It ended the week one of their contacts was found with his phone missing and his hands broken. The official explanation was robbery. The journalist didn’t dispute it. Instead, he gave her a thumb drive with names, photos, and aliases of people in multiple countries known to be involved in human rights abuses.
“Do whatever you want with it,” he said. “It’s the only copy I have. I don’t know if there are others.”
She didn’t ask what would happen if she turned it in. She handed it over and two weeks later she was on a plane to New York for her latest assignment.
She stirred the foam in her cappuccino, then looked up at him.
“You said you should feel differently about the marches. Why don’t you?”
He shifted in his chair. “There’s pressure to do that, isn’t there? You live in a city like this, you work with people who care. Or say they do. And if you express doubt, you get that look.”
“Not from me,” she said.
“At the end of the day I suppose it’s catharsis,” he said. “People need to shout, be seen. Then go back to their lives.”
“Now you sound pessimistic.”
“Realistic, I’d say.”
She leaned back. “In Istanbul, there were marches every weekend. Mostly women. Holding photos. Chanting names.”
He sensed there was more, but he didn’t press her.
“I’ve seen it build up slow,” she said, “and end with violence. Some go away and don’t come back. But here, we’re not that kind of state. The pressure is subtle. Jobs vanish, money tightens, articles get buried, funding dries up.”
“Subtle? Nothing that’s happening is subtle.”
“The military’s not on streetcorners like everyone thought.”
He tapped the table. “Now you sound like someone who works in intelligence.”
She laughed. “Not quite.”
They let the pause stretch. She took a sip. He stared out the window.
“I’ve told you about myself. You haven’t said a thing about what you do.”
“I’m with Brooklyn Legal Defenders,” he said. “Mostly immigration cases.”
Her eyebrows lifted. “Interesting.”
“With an easier caseload, it could be,” he said. “It’s important, so I’m willing to do what it takes. Now more than ever we’re on the front lines.”
“Lot of court appearances.”
“Every week. Some wins, some delays, a lot of administrative limbo. Sometimes you know the judge’s mind before you enter the court. Other times, you get surprised.”
“Surprised how?”
“They let someone stay.”
She nodded. “So, removal defense?”
“Among other things. I have a few clients in detention. One’s been in nine months. No charges against him, he sits and waits. His wife and kids don’t know what to do.”
“That’s sad.”
He exhaled. “It is. We file motions, we appeal. Some days it feels like I’m bailing water in a sinking boat. But then I get someone out and see them hug their family. For a while it feels like the law worked, I accomplished something.”
She waited a moment, then said, “I’m more comfortable liaising between humanitarian agencies and uncooperative government partners.”
“That’s vague.”
“It was meant to be.”
“And you’re still at it.”
“I am. It’s a slightly different role than I’ve had. That’s what I like about it.”
They talked a little longer, until he glanced at his phone.
“I invited you, but now I need to run. My basketball team has a game over at the Milton Street courts. Refs and all. It can’t be missed. We’re fighting for a playoff spot.”
“Sounds like fun. All I’ve got is a report to write. The sooner I get it out of the way, the easier my week will be.”
Outside, Meserole was quiet. A man walked by with his dog. Across the street, three people in conversation lingered on the corner.
Back in the lobby, waiting for the elevator, he said, “We should do this again.”
“Yes,” she said. “Let me get back to you on that.”
He raised an eyebrow. “Non-committal.”
“But interested.”
He laughed once, low. “Same café?”
“Or somewhere with adult beverages,” she said.
He gave a slight nod. “You’ll let me know?”
“I’ll do that, James.”
The next morning, Mia sat at her desk and typed three names. One was new. His.
She didn’t yet know if he was a target or just peripheral. His name had surfaced in a routine crawl of protest communications. A few hits were all. But he was outspoken in his role at Brooklyn Legal Defenders. Several of his high-profile cases had caught someone’s attention. He wasn’t afraid to face the cameras. The rest, his social ties, habits, and loyalties was her job to sort out.
Before doing that, she was told to keep contact with him casual. To let it unfold in a natural way, as it had so far.
The two others on her list were more urgent, but even with those assignments pressing, her thoughts circled back to him. In several panel talks he’d cited Cedric J. Robinson and Nicholas De Genova. Once, in an interview, he quoted Robinson’s line: “The state has always been the defender of the dominant.” In another interview he argued that immigration law functioned less to protect the vulnerable than to regulate low-wage labor.
It wasn’t much, just names he’d invoked and phrases he repeated. Unremarkable lines they may be, but in her work, they were signs of something larger taking shape. That became her baseline for evaluating him. He wasn’t recruiting. He wasn’t grandstanding on streetcorners or circulating leaflets or appearing on online panels. He was doing a job he believed was vital.
That belief unsettled her. It wasn’t an act; he said the same things in public as he did when they were alone. She recognized conviction when she saw it, and conviction was often harder to control than ambition.
- Subject’s rhetoric consistent with private views
- Potential influence exceeds profile
She finished writing, saved the file, got dressed, and went to her midtown office, the previous day’s conversation with him still turning in her mind.
Later that afternoon, she texted him:
Hey, catch 22 tomorrow night in the clubroom. you going? haven’t seen it.
- Neither have i
The film was playing when she got there. The room was dark, folding chairs faced the pull-down screen, a table with wine and plastic cups set near the door. A brief burst of laughter rose over the movie’s dialogue.
She spotted him in a corner chair holding a bottle of beer, next to a woman with dyed red hair, a guy in wire-rim glasses, and her neighbor Robert, who sat beside the woman.
She poured a cup of wine, slipped into the same row, and took a chair near him.
He leaned forward and said in a low voice, “Good to see you.”
“And you,” she kept her voice low as his.
“Mia,” he said to the others.
A change of scene on the screen.
“Wait, what did he say?” someone near them asked.
“There’s no telling what people might find out once they feel free to ask the questions they want to.”
By the time Yossarian understood the secret revealed by Snowden’s death, the laughter had stopped.
The credits rolled in silence. The lights came on.
“Well,” Robert said. “That was bleak.”
“It’s not what I thought it would be,” Mia said.
“What did you expect?”
“More satire. Less gut punch.”
He glanced at her. “You think it still applies?”
“To bureaucracy? To power? Of course. You do too, I’m pretty sure.”
People stood, poured more wine, cracked beers. James introduced her to his friends, Robert, Beth, Lily the redhead, and Harold.
Lily shook her hand. “Welcome to the building.”
“My company said good things about it. Looks like they were right.”
The guy with glasses introduced himself as Harold. “We’ve all been here a while.”
“Not sure how long for me. On a sublease right now.”
“Mia’s done some interesting work overseas,” he said. “Frankfurt, then Istanbul, and others, I believe.”
Lily nodded. “What do you do?”
“Project coordination, mostly,” she said. “Following up on initiatives, compiling findings, nothing glamorous.”
Harold grinned. “When people say that I always assume it’s the opposite.”
Lily asked: “Did you miss being out of the country for so long?”
She smiled. “Sometimes I did, sure. But I found Istanbul fascinating. I wanted to stay longer. Unfortunately, that didn’t work out.”
Lily concurred about Istanbul. She was there before COVID. She wanted to see more of Turkey.
“Is it still safe to travel there?” she asked Mia.
“Sure, so long as you don’t get involved in anything political,” Mia said.
“Same as here,” Robert said.
They stayed on that until the conversation thinned. James checked his phone and leaned toward her. “Time for me to head out.”
She nodded. “Me too.”
They left together. In the lobby they went to the elevators.
“It’s one of those films where madness feels like the most rational response,” Mia said.
He didn’t answer right away. Then, “Do you want to come up? I happen to have an unopened bottle of wine.”
“Imagine that.”
“I really have two, which means I need to get rid of one. Declutter and all that.”
“How about if I take a rain check.”
“That’s fine. Rain checks don’t expire. And most wines get better with age, or so I’m told.”
They watched the numbers tick down. Each pause between floors tightening the silence.
Two weeks later they had dinner at Achilles Heel, a popular gastropub a short walk from their building. Afterward they stopped at his place for a nightcap. It was disordered but clean; books leaning in uneven rows, a half-closed laptop on the couch, yellow pads stacked on the desk, sneakers tucked under a low table.
He poured her a glass of wine and they stood by the window.
“You struck me more as a shot and beer guy.”
“I confess, I drink wine when I’m trying to impress.”
“I do like your view better than mine.”
“See that cleared-out lot. That’s going to be forty-five stories and block it. Yours faces east, I know.”
“Spying on me?”
“Nah. Everyone in the building talks about everyone else. You will to.”
“I like your friends,” she said. “They’re smart. Passionate. At least that’s the impression I got in the little time I was with them.”
“I like them too. They’re the real thing. They don’t pretend.”
“And you?”
“Me what?”
He looked at her. She let the quiet hold a moment, wanting to remember the way he looked just then. They set their glasses down and embraced, then kissed. It wasn’t awkward or rushed, more like something understood.
In time they went to his bedroom. The bed was made, books stacked in a neat pile on the table next to it. They undressed each other, in no hurry. On the bed, she straddled him for a moment, then eased down beside him and stayed the night.
After that, they saw each other a few days a week. They ate together and woke up together. On mornings she went to her office, they walked to the subway. Weekends were spent going for runs, or to the movies, or getting together with his friends; outside of her work she hadn’t made many of her own yet.
Weekdays, he did most of the cooking. She was surprised how good his pasta dishes were. Each visit she brought Argentine wine, a favorite from her time in Buenos Aires.
Six weeks after their first get-together, James brought her to a gathering in the basement of a church on Kent Street. More than a hundred people filled the room. Two tables had stacks of flyers and printouts with legal-aid contacts, court-procedure guides, and a zine called Survival offering instructions for when someone was taken in.
People milled around with paper cups of water and tea, talking in low voices. His friends Robert, Beth, Lily, and others greeted him first, then turned to her with kind words.
At the front, a bearded man with a hoarse voice gave a rundown to a circle of listeners, describing the observation he believed they were under.
“At least one is here, count on it,” he said, nodding at the crowd.
Others debated the next steps: push for direct action, counter-messaging campaigns.
Mia noticed how people deferred to him and Beth, how eager Lily was to express her own ideas.
She took it in. A man nearby talked about facial recognition software spreading through the city. She’d heard the same fears in other places, in other languages. The pattern was familiar: the quiet dread that came with knowing that once you were marked as a threat in the system, there was no way out.
She held a sheet in her hands that mapped upcoming court dates and actions. The precision reminded her of briefing charts she used make. She admired it even as she registered who the real organizers were; yes, James was one. She watched who dominated the discussion, who leaned in.
When someone passed around a list of mutual aid tasks, community organizing, solidarity efforts, and the like, James signed up for two without hesitation. When it was offered to her, Mia said she’d check her schedule. That was fine.
Later, on the walk back, he said, “You didn’t say much.”
She shrugged. “I don’t usually the first time I meet people. Maybe I try to not say anything that might come off as foolish.”
“I guess we’re all that way until we get comfortable enough to be ourselves.”
“Your friends are important to you. I see how you have this in common.”
“This should be everyone’s concern all the time.”
As the ease between them grew, he started talking about his work, the detention hearings, bond requests, and how prosecutors chose which cases to pursue. He caught himself slipping into a kind of flat legal language and wondered if she was bored with it. Still, he kept going, about whether someone could qualify for cancellation of removal, how hard it was to prove good moral character, what it took to make a case for relief. He never said deportation, though it hung over everything.
She listened, part of her impressed with his dedication, another part storing away his opinions of the process, knowing they’d end up in her next report.
In return, she told him half-truths. Not lies, but careful omissions. Yes, she’d been in Frankfurt as she said. She’d worked in Latin America. She’d witnessed violence. She was tired of chaos. Sometimes, when she spoke, she caught a look in his eyes, like he knew there was more she wasn’t telling him.
He liked asking her questions when she least expected it, in the middle of brushing her teeth, or walking home with takeout Mexican.
“How long do you think you can do this? Did you ever think of trying something else?”
“Sometimes,” she said. “Then I remember I don’t have a single marketable skill.”
He laughed. “That’s not true. You see things most people miss.”
“Proves my point,” she said, meeting his eyes in the mirror.
He didn’t ask her about other men. Though he was curious about the romantic life of someone who moved around as much as she did. He hinted at it until she confessed about those who had their time and place. Brief affairs. One or two nighters. A week if they liked each other.
“You gotta do what you gotta do,” she said, and laughed.
A connection, or several of them, at every stop in the way a sailor had one at every port, he presumed.
“Is that what I am?” he said.
She took a moment, then said, “I hadn’t thought of you that way, but I see how you might come to that conclusion.”
He didn’t talk much about his past. He wasn’t hiding it. Compared to the importance of his work, it didn’t seem worth going into. She knew about him, of course. But over the weeks she let him tell her anyway. He grew up in Hartford, went to Cornell Law, spent a few years at a big firm. The money was good. A lot more than he was making now, ten years later. He left for his own reasons. He didn’t like the ruthless pursuit of billable hours, the intense pressure, the burnout. He wasn’t doing what he set out to do.
“And now?”
“It isn’t what I imagined,” he said, “but it’s better than helping the rich, powerful, and corporate get away with what everyone else can’t afford.”
He didn’t mention his arrest and she didn’t press him on it. She knew the dustup it had caused. The humiliation of being brought to his knees then dropped face down while his hands were zip-tied. She imagined the anger that must continue to simmer in him over it.
As the weeks went on, they saw more of each other, enough so his friends began to feel neglected. She wanted to be taken into the group more, but he kept her away. She thought it due to her lack of enthusiasm for the cause. In fact, despite their tightening bond, he wasn’t sure of her loyalties, or if she leaned one way or another. She was confusing to him at the same time he wanted to be with her.
She had no choice but to accept the space he held between them. She didn’t push it. She knew trust, like suspicion, could grow without words.
Once, while he was in the shower, she opened his desk drawer. Inside was a stack of old ID badges and access stickers held together by a rubber band, all arranged in chronological order. They came from conferences, legal clinics, law school. She paused over a younger, defiant face. Behind it was a badge from an organization she knew, a group that had once documented raids on immigrant communities, that collapsed after a series of internal leaks.
For a moment, she felt her chest tighten. Was it admiration, or guilt? She wasn’t sure. She checked out the rest, making mental notes, then slid the drawer shut before he finished. She left the two thumb drives untouched.
The online video report she filed to her supervisor the next day was brief.
“He’s not central,” she said. “Connected, yes. But not a planner. Not a recruiter. Not a mouthpiece.”
“And the others?”
“They trust him.”
“Do you?”
“I do,” she said.
On a Tuesday night in late October, warm for the season, they sat on a bench by the river watching the ferries zigzag across the river.
She broke a silent moment.
“Were you ever arrested?”
He looked at her sideways. “Once. I spent two nights inside. Then I was released. They dropped the charges.”
“What was it for?”
“Refusing to leave a sit-in at the lobby of a federal contractor. We were protesting a surveillance program. No one paid attention. It was just after the midterms. Everyone was exhausted.”
“You were part of a group?”
He nodded. “A loose one. We didn’t make public statements. Most of what we did was invisible work. Exposing ties between agencies, and the companies that say they’re neutral. Stuff like that.”
“Are they still around?”
“In a way, yes.”
“And you’re still involved with them?”
“To a degree. Some things are better left to the ones who aren’t defending people in the courts.”
He turned to look at her. “Why do you ask?”
“I was just thinking. You seem to keep a lot to yourself. Or so I imagine.”
“I don’t mean to. I just… I’m careful. I have to be. People’s lives are at stake. Their families. You’re not exactly forthright about everything you do. I can see through that too.”
She held his gaze. “I don’t volunteer what I think might be misunderstood.”
“Or maybe you don’t say things you think might matter later.”
There was no annoyance in his voice. It was more a quiet recognition, like he’d accepted this about her. She didn’t reply right away. Instead, she leaned back and stared at the skyline across the water.
“I don’t always know which version of myself to explain,” she said.
He nodded, as if that made sense to him. “Then maybe we’re the same in that way.”
“Maybe that’s our attraction.”
“A few years ago, I filed a motion in a case I wasn’t supposed to touch. It exposed how local law enforcement was sharing detainee data with a private contractor. The feds hadn’t asked for it. There was no oversight. Just an agreement and an open port. I found out about it, flagged it in court, and sent a redacted version to a reporter I trusted. She went dark for over a month. When she resurfaced, it was with a story about coastal erosion and rising tides. She never wrote about the leak.
“What did that tell you?”
“That trust is dangerous. The system doesn’t need to silence you, it just drowns you out. And if you push, it won’t hesitate to break you.”
She felt the weight of what he said, and what he didn’t. It left a dull ache in her. Was it guilt or something closer to sorrow? She couldn’t tell.
She waited three days before reporting it. It wasn’t that she doubted what he’d told her. It was hard to decide if it was important enough to escalate. What he’d done was small stuff. Minor interferences, like a slow leak, not a rupture. But it fit a pattern. His friends. The spaces he moved in. The people and places he called out by name. He wasn’t sympathetic to resistance. He was a part of it.
And by her silence, so was she.
Despite what went on below the surface, they carried on as couples do. One sunny Saturday, they biked to Dumbo and ate burgers at an outdoor table. Another weekend they went to Montauk, walking along the beach each morning and evening.
She felt herself softening. It was dangerous; her training had repeated that forbidden word. The instructions were always the same: report it, then step away.
The morning after they got back from Montauk, Mia met her contact on online video.
“He trusts me,” she said.
“And…”
“We’ve slept together.”
“Was that your initiative?”
“It was mutual. It wasn’t planned, of course.”
The woman stared at her, waiting for more.
“He’s not an agitator. He’s linked to active operations. He knows key people. He’s helped raise funds.”
“It’s the first time you’ve mentioned this.”
“I wasn’t sure it mattered.”
“You weren’t sure? You know everything matters.”
Mia went silent.
“We’ll need verification. You have documentation?”
“Some, not a lot,” Mia said. “I didn’t want to push too hard. If I did, he’d disappear.”
“You need to find out what else you can get from him. And I’ll need a report.”
It took a few moments for Mia to answer. “I’ll see what I can do.”
Mia spent the rest of the day turning it over in her head. There were ten different versions of how to say it. None of them felt right.
Two nights later it rained. At his invitation she went to the third floor. He made dinner for them, an eggplant, plum tomato, and rigatoni dish with red pepper flakes and garlic. It had an intense flavor.
“Delicious,” she said.
After it, they sat on the couch drinking the wine she’d brought. Argentine, as usual. Outside, it continued to rain.
“I always enjoy the wine you bring,” he said.
“Not as much as I enjoy your pasta dishes.”
“I’ll accept the compliment.”
“You should. They don’t come around often. Or that’s been my experience.”
They went quiet until she said, “I have to tell you something.”
He didn’t move, but she felt his attention shift.
She waited until she was ready.
“I wasn’t sent to New York for the job I told you about.”
He looked at her, not startled, more curious than anything.
“I was sent to monitor political groups. Certain people. Now, that includes you.”
He nodded once, and said, “I know.”
She blinked. “You know.”
“I’ve known for a while. We all have. That’s why I never invited you to another meeting.”
“How?”
“It was the small things, the details hidden in your questions, the things you let slip that you couldn’t have known otherwise.”
He took a sip.
“And then there’s the way you watch and listen. Like someone deciding which part of a story is useful.”
Mia felt her mouth go dry. “Why didn’t you say anything?”
He turned his glass in his hand. “I wasn’t sure how far you’d go. I was curious. So, I guess it’s this far.”
“You don’t want to know who I work for?”
He shook his head. “Does it matter? Would it change anything? You work for them. That’s all I need to know.”
She looked at him. He seemed tired, not hurt. And to her that was worse.
“I didn’t expect to care,” she said in a high voice. “Not about you.”
“I know,” he said again. “That part I believe.”
They sat in silence as the rain dripped down the window.
He didn’t ask her to leave. He didn’t reach for her. He knew that was it. She did too.
He watched her stand. He noticed the pale green ring again, the way she turned it once with her thumb before she thanked him for dinner and walked to the door. He didn’t move, his eyes following her into the hallway until the door shut.
Paul Perilli, Perilli’s writing has appeared in numerous literary publications. His website is https://paulperilli.com/.




Comments